The D.C. Circuit Leaves Undisturbed the Ability of Employers to Ban Union Communications Using Corporate E-Mail
Many had anticipated a dramatic rejection of Register-Guard, the National Labor Relations Board's landmark December 2007 decision, which held that employees could not use their employer's e-mail system as a matter of right to engage in union-related activities or union solicitation (see our previous blog entry). Instead, on July 7, 2009, the D.C. Circuit let that decision stand, effectively holding that the newspaper in that case did not violate federal law by issuing a policy banning all solicitations, including union solicitations, from its corporate e-mail system.
The court nonetheless concluded that the newspaper had engaged in unfair labor practices in the way it applied the policy. The court found that one of the e-mails that resulted in discipline of the employee—who was also the union president—was union-related, but was not a solicitation. Consequently, the union president did not violate the newspaper’s electronic resources policy by sending it. The other two e-mails upon which the newspaper had relied to discipline the employee were solicitations that violated the company’s policy. However, the newspaper's lax enforcement of the policy vis-à-vis non-union-related messages and its after-the-fact justification for applying the policy to the employee's messages demonstrated unlawful discrimination against union activities.
Continue Reading...